HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 10 Exclusive Garbage Collection Franchise Ordinance AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY Meeting Date: 6/5/2017
Meeting Type: Regular Meeting
Staff Contact/Dept.: Anette Spickard, DPW
Staff Phone No: 541/726-3753
Estimated Time: 10 minutes
S P R I N G F I E L D C I T Y C O U N C I L Council Goals: Provide Financially Responsible and Innovative Government Services
ITEM TITLE: EXCLUSIVE GARBAGE COLLECTION FRANCHISE ORDINANCE
ACTION REQUESTED: Conduct a public hearing and first reading of following ordinance: AN ORDINANCE REGARDING THE EXCLUSIVE GARBAGE COLLECTION FRANCHISE OF THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, TO PROVIDE FOR NEW OPPORTUNITY TO RECYCLE ACT REQUIREMENTS, AND RESTATING THE FRANCHISE, AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 6011 (SPECIAL), AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE NO. 6309 (GENERAL) (FIRST READING).
ISSUE
STATEMENT:
The Oregon legislature has revised the Opportunity to Recycle Act law and the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality has adopted rules implementing the law, necessitating an update to the
language in the City’s exclusive garbage collection franchise ordinance.
ATTACHMENTS: Attachment 1: Council Briefing Memo of May 15, 2017 Attachment 2: Proposed Ordinance
DISCUSSION/
FINANCIAL
IMPACT:
The Opportunity to Recycle Act is found in ORS Chapter 459A and was revised during the 2015
legislative session. New administrative rules have since been adopted by the Oregon Department of
Environmental Quality (DEQ) to implement the new provisions of the law. The City of Springfield,
by virtue of our population size and proximity to Portland, is required to comply with the new laws
and administrative regulations by January 1, 2018. At the May 15, 2017 Council work session, staff briefed Council on the new requirements and proposed a new set of program elements that can be implemented by both the City and Sanipac to maintain our compliance with the law with the least financial impact to rate payers. (Attachment 1) To prepare for the January 1, 2018 deadline, staff proposes replacing the current ordinance No. 6011 (Special) with the proposed ordinance (Attachment 2) which includes revised language in Section 6 – Opportunity to Recycle Act. This language is to ensure that Sanipac provides the programs that qualify the City for compliance with the Act. New language is also proposed in this section to require Sanipac
to prepare the City’s annual Opportunity to Recycle report for the DEQ. Lastly, this section also makes
clear that the City has the authority to approve the recycling and waste prevention programs that are
delivered by Sanipac to comply with the Act.
All other terms and conditions remain.
M E M O R A N D U M City of Springfield
Date: 5/8/2017
COUNCIL
BRIEFING
MEMORANDUM
To: Gino Grimaldi
From: Anette Spickard, Development and Public Works
Director
Subject: Sanipac Franchise Update and Rate Increase
ISSUE: 1. Sanipac, the City’s franchise hauler for solid waste, has requested an increase in rates
effective July 1, 2017 based on both a CPI increase and the increase in costs to comply with the County’s new requirement that all commercial haulers deliver waste to Short Mountain Landfill effective July 1, 2017.
2. The Franchise Ordinance needs to be updated to include new DEQ requirements for recycling and waste prevention programs.
COUNCIL GOALS/MANDATE:
Financially Responsible and Stable Government Services
BACKGROUND: Sanipac’s last CPI increase was granted by Council in July 2014. In May
2016 Sanipac was granted a 1.79% rate increase based on the increase in tipping fees imposed by Lane County in 2016. During that work session staff informed the Council of the County’s
pending update to their 20 year Solid Waste Master Plan which included the tipping fee increase
along with proposed changes to the system of transfer stations such as disallowing commercial haulers at the Glenwood Transfer Station. The Board of Commissioners has since adopted the
recommendations and effective July 1, 2017 all commercial haulers must deliver their loads to
Short Mountain Landfill. This change is expected to reduce costs for the County’s operation of the solid waste system but will impact transportation costs for waste haulers such as Sanipac.
DISCUSSION:
Rates: Sanipac has requested a 2.1% CPI adjustment, which is less than the allowable CPI adjustment provided by the Franchise Ordinance. The Franchise allows Council to consider a
rate increase based on the most recent January Portland CPI-U, which for January 2017 is 2.6%. Sanipac has also calculated a 0.81% cost increase associated with the new County requirement to haul all loads to Short Mountain. Together the proposed rate increase results in $0.40 more
per month for the most frequently used service. A summary of the current rates and proposed rates for each type of service is included as Attachment 3. Staff from Sanipac will be present at the worksession to answer questions.
Franchise Update: Staff will provide Council an overview of the new recycling and waste prevention requirements of Oregon’s Recycling Opportunity Act (See Attachment 4). Staff has
worked closely with DEQ, Sanipac, and Lane County to determine what changes are needed to
ensure Springfield is in compliance with the new law as of January 2018. Since Sanipac’s Franchise is renewed each October 1, staff proposes including updated language in the Franchise
Ordinance to reflect these new requirements prior to Council summer recess so that the City can
demonstrate compliance with the new law prior to January 2018. Sanipac does not anticipate an increase in rates in order to comply with the new requirements.
Senate Bill 263 (2015) Overview of Requirements:
The law has two components – Recycling Programs and Waste Prevention Programs. Due to Springfield’s population size and our proximity to Portland, the new law requires Springfield to
provide seven recycling program elements and five waste prevention program elements.
Springfield currently provides five of the recycling program elements, therefore the City must add two more recycling program elements plus add the five waste prevention program elements.
Staff proposes the City provide the following seven Recycling Program elements as they are already in practice and can be implemented with minimal cost and impact to Springfield
Attachment 1, Page 1 of 2
residents and businesses.
1. Residential recycling containers (currently provide)
2. Expanded Education and Promotion Program (currently provide but new requirement for a Contamination Reduction Education Plan which Sanipac will prepare in coordination with DEQ and EcoSort.)
3. Residential yard debris collection and composting (currently provide) 4. Commercial and Institutional recycling (currently provide)
5. Commercial and Institutional composting (currently provide)
6. Multifamily recycling required by city code (need to review/update existing code plus landlord outreach) 7. Commercial recycling required in city code (new code needed, but already in practice)
Staff proposes the City provide the following five Waste Prevention Program elements as they are already in practice or the new elements can be implemented by Sanipac using DEQ approved
templates.
1. Community-wide general promotion of waste prevention (continue Sanipac newsletters, website and media campaign)
2. Residential waste prevention campaign (Sanipac will use new DEQ approved templates)
3. Commercial waste prevention campaign (Sanipac will use new DEQ approved templates)
4. Schools waste prevention campaign (Sanipac currently offers food waste reduction tool kits and equipment free of charge to Springfield school cafeterias. Will need to implement at one middle school. Sanipac will also provide a waste prevention education
activity to all 4th graders as part of the City’s Public Works week.) 5. Food rescue program support (City is in compliance with this element already by providing CDBG funds to Food for Lane County through the Human Services
Commission.)
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Staff recommends approval of the requested rate increase in commercial and residential rates for
all categories of waste collection as allowed by section 16.4.b of the franchise agreement.
Staff recommends the City provide the seven recycling program elements and five waste prevention program elements of SB263 and update the Franchise Ordinance to ensure the City is
in compliance with Oregon’s Recycling Opportunity Act by January 2018. Based on Council feedback, staff will prepare an updated Franchise Ordinance for public hearing.
Attachment 1, Page 2 of 2
PAGE 1 of 5
CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, OREGON
ORDINANCE NO. ___________ (SPECIAL) AN ORDINANCE REGARDING THE EXCLUSIVE GARBAGE COLLECTION·FRANCHISE OF THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD, TO PROVIDE FOR NEW OPPORTUNITY TO RECYCLE REQUIREMENTS, AND RESTATING THE FRANCHISE, AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 6011 (SPECIAL), AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE NO. 6309 (GENERAL)
THE COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SPRINGFIELD ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Previous Ordinances. Ordinance No. 2366 (Special) approved February 10,
1969 granted to Springfield Sanitary Service, an Oregon corporation doing business in
Springfield, Oregon, the exclusive right, franchise and privilege of collecting and hauling over
the streets of the City of Springfield, all garbage and refuse as defined in Article 4-2-1 of the Springfield Code, 1965 and that franchise was extended by Ordinance No. 3164 (Special)
approved May 5, 1975 for the period from March 1, 1979 until March 1, 1989, and was further
extended for a rolling five year period by Ordinance 5395 (Special), approved June 22, 1987,
and thereafter further amended by Ordinance No. 5621 (Special), approved March 16, 1992,
and thereafter further amended by Ordinance No. 6011 (Special) approved May 20, 2002,
Sanipac, Inc. is the successor business entity to Springfield Sanitary Service. This Ordinance fully
restates the entire franchise granted by the City of Springfield and all prior ordinances are hereby repealed and of no further force and effect.
Section 2. Grant of Franchise. It is hereby granted to Sanipac, Inc., an Oregon
corporation, doing business in Springfield, Oregon, hereinafter referred to as "Franchisee", the exclusive right, franchise and privilege of collecting and hauling over the streets within the City of
Springfield all garbage and refuse as defined in Section 4.400, et seq., of the Springfield
Municipal Code.
Section 3. Exceptions to Grant of Franchise. The exclusive right, privilege, and franchise
granted under Section 2 is subject to the following exceptions:
(a) A person may transport solid waste which such person produces, directly to an authorized disposal site or recycling or resource recovery facility; Provided, however, the solid
waste produced by tenant, licensee, occupant or person other than the owner of the leased,
occupied or licensed premises may be considered produced by the landlord or property owner;
but provided further, owners or groups of owners may not join for the purpose of commercially
transporting solid waste from properties of differing ownership.
(b) A person may contract with the State or a federal agency to provide service to
such agency under a written contract with such agency. (c) A person may engage in the practice of towing or otherwise removing damaged,
discarded or abandoned vehicles or parts thereof, so long as such activity is conducted in
compliance with applicable state and local laws.
(d) A person may engage in the practice of pumping, transportation, and disposal of
septic tank and cesspool pumpings or other sludge, provided such activity is conducted in
compliance with applicable state and local laws.
(e) A person who engages in an occupation, such as gardener, landscaper, grounds
keeper, or construction contractor for a property owner or tenant in the City and who produces
thereby small volumes of solid waste as a result of such work for a property owner or tenant in
the City may transport such solid waste in such person's own equipment where the solid waste
produced is incidental to the particular job the person is performing.
Attachment 2, Page 1 of 5
PAGE 2 of 5
Section 4. Fee. In consideration of the granting of the privilege, right and franchise, the
Franchisee hereby agrees to pay the City of Springfield a franchise fee, payable quarterly, equal
to seven percent of its gross receipts less that portion of user fees collected for remittance to Lane
County. That franchise fee is to be computed from certified financial statement from the franchise
holder, setting forth the number of residential and commercial accounts in its franchise area and the receipts received therefrom. Payments made hereunder shall be made on or before October 15,
January 15, April l5, and July 15. Such payments may be estimated based on information available at
the time payments are due and then adjusted following receipt, by the franchise holder, of an audited
annual financial statement. City shall have upon reasonable notice right of access to Franchisee's
accounts and records relating to the collection of solid waste in Springfield.
Section 5. Additional Fee, Free Service to City. As further and additional compensation,
the Franchisee shall remove all garbage and miscellaneous refuse from the following administrative
buildings and offices of the City of Springfield: the City Hall/Library/Museum complex, maintenance
shops, fire stations, the police and court administration buildings, and other administrative offices,
including disposal at the Lane County land fill of material removed from City streets by City street sweepers.
Section 6. Opportunity to Recycle Must be Provided. As a condition of the rights, privilege
and franchise given hereunder, the Franchisee shall be required to provide all customers within the
City of Springfield the opportunity to recycle and must comply with the requirements of ORS Chapter
459A, together with all applicable rules and regulations promulgated thereunder by the State of
Oregon Department of Environmental Quality. Franchisee shall annually prepare a certification report for the Oregon Department of Environment Quality demonstrating Springfield’s compliance with the
Opportunity to Recycle Act. The City shall approve the program elements utilized by the Franchisee
to comply with the Opportunity to Recycle Act.
Section 7. Term. The rights, privilege and franchise herein granted to Franchisee shall be
commenced on the 1st day of October, 1987, and shall be considered as a continuing five (5) year
franchise as specified in this section. Beginning on October 1 of each year, the franchise will be considered renewed for an additional one (1) year term, unless at least thirty (30) days prior to
October 1 of any year the City shall notify Franchisee in writing of the intent to terminate the
franchise. Upon the giving of such notice of termination, the Franchisee shall have a franchise which
will terminate five (5) years from the date of notice of termination. After such notification, the City may extend the term or reinstate the continuing renewal upon mutual agreement with the Franchisee.
Nothing in this section restricts the City of suspending, modifying or revoking the franchise for cause
pursuant to Section 14 of this franchise.
Section 8. Annexed Areas. The rights and privileges of this franchise shall not extend to
any future additions to the City of Springfield except that this franchise shall automatically extend to
include annexed areas to the City of Springfield at such time as the Franchisee shall have as customers 100% of the customers having garbage collection service in said area; said area shall thereupon be
covered and governed by this franchise held by the Franchisee and Granted hereby.
Section 9. Termination by Franchisee. In the event the Franchisee shall desire to terminate service given under the terms of this franchise, then it shall give not less than two years' notice of the
intent to terminate service and obligations under the franchise. In the event of a voluntary
termination of service by the Franchisee, the City shall have a right and option to purchase all or any
part of the equipment of the Franchisee at a price which will be agreed upon between the parties. If
the parties cannot agree to a purchase price, then the same shall be submitted to arbitration. Each
party shall select one arbitrator and the two arbitrators selected shall select a third party, and the
Attachment 2, Page 2 of 5
PAGE 3 of 5
three arbitrators shall determine a fair and equitable price to be paid by the City to the Franchisee for
all equipment to be purchased. The costs of arbitration shall be borne equally.
Section 10. Indemnification. Franchisee shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless the City
from and against any and all claims, suits, causes of action, loss or liability arising out of or related to any activity of Franchisee, its agents and employees in the performance of this franchise.
Section 11. Emergency Service by City. The Franchisee agrees as a condition of holding the
franchise, that whenever the City Council determines that the failure of service or threatened failure
of service would result in the creation of an immediate and serious health hazard, the City may, after
a minimum of twenty-four (24) hours' written notice to the Franchisee, and a public hearing if
requested by the Franchisee, authorize City personnel or other persons to temporarily provide the
service or to use and operate the land, facilities and/or equipment of Franchisee. The City may
authorize expenses which are necessary to provide the service which Franchisee is required to provide
under this franchise. The City shall return any seized property and the business of Franchisee, upon
abatement of the actual or threatened interruption of service.
If City is required to perform the services pursuant to this Paragraph, City may bill Franchisee
for the cost of providing the same and Franchisee shall reimburse the City for the actual cost of
providing the services within ten (10) days after receipt of the City's bill. In the event Franchisee fails
to reimburse the City within ten (10) days after receipt of the City's cost bill, City may employ all
rights and remedies to which it may be entitled under law to secure payment of the cost bill.
Franchisee shall be entitled to all customer account income arising from the provision of
the service by the City or other persons pursuant to this Section.
Section 12. Franchisee Assistance to Beautification Activities. Franchisee agrees, as a condition to holding the franchise, to assist City in clean-up and beautification activities by
supplying free drop-boxes to City on the following terms:
(1) Franchisee agrees to provide a total of ten (10) drop-boxes to City during each calendar
year for a period not to exceed seventy-two (72) hours for each drop-box, which shall be used by City
for refuse collection.
(2) Franchisee, upon forty-eight (48) hours' notice by City, shall deliver each box to the site
specified by City, and at the end of the seventy-two (72) hour period, Franchisee shall have the right to remove the drop-box and dispose of the material contained in the drop- box at a location of
Franchisee's choice.
(3) City shall be responsible for obtaining a waiver of dump fees from Lane County, or paying
of such dump fees if Lane County will not waive the dump fees for the ten (10) drop-boxes. All other
costs of delivery and removal of the boxes shall be Franchisee's costs.
(4) Franchisee's responsibility for the delivery and removal of the ten (10) drop-boxes shall be
limited to the period from November h through March 31 of the following calendar year, during the term of Franchisee's franchise. It is understood that if the City requests five (5) or fewer drop-boxes
at any one time, Franchisee will probably be able to provide that number at any time during the
calendar year.
Section 13. Sanitary Trucks. All trucks for the collection of garbage and refuse used and
operated by the Franchisee shall be packer-type enclosed trucks, and shall be designed to be water-
tight and drip-proof, so that no garbage or waste water may at any time spill or drip upon the
streets of the City. All equipment used by the Franchisee shall be kept and maintained in a clean
and inoffensive manner and shall be thoroughly washed, at least once a week or as often as
directed by the health officer of the City. It is understood and agreed that the Franchisee shall add
Attachment 2, Page 3 of 5
PAGE 4 of 5
to its equipment as it may become necessary in order to properly and in a sanitary manner collect
the garbage and refuse within the City limits and to transport the same as herein provided, and
there shall at all times be sufficient equipment to comply with the terms of this franchise.
All storage, collection, transportation and disposal of solid waste shall conform to the applicable requirements of Oregon Revised Chapter 459 and regulations promulgated thereunder by the State
Department of Environmental Quality.
Section 14. Termination by City for Cause. In addition to the provision for termination of the
franchise as provided in Section 7, it is also understood and a condition of this franchise that should
the Franchisee fail, neglect or refuse to perform any of the terms, provisions or stipulations of this
agreement by Grantee to be performed, then after providing appropriate notice to the Franchisee and
time to correct the failure, or in the event of neglect or refusal to perform by Franchisee, the City shall
have the right to cancel this agreement and franchise. Such cancellation may be carried out by the
City in the event that there are any repeated uncorrected violations of this franchise, and such
cancellation shall be accomplished in the following manner: The City Manager shall keep a record in writing of repeated uncorrected violations, and shall at such time as in the City Manager’s discretion
the same is warranted, call for an explanation thereof by the Franchisee to the Common Council and
thereupon, if the Common Council at its own sole discretion shall deem it in the best interests of the City that this franchise be cancelled, then the same shall be forthwith cancelled by the Council by
nothing further than a resolution to that effect, and such findings and actions on the part of the
Council shall be conclusive. It is further understood that continued repeated violations, even though
corrected, shall constitute evidence of bad faith on the part of the Franchisee, and shall in and of itself be sufficient basis for the City Manager to call upon the Franchisee for an explanation before the
Council in the manner above stated to the end that this franchise may thereupon be cancelled.
Section 15. Rates. Rates for the collection of garbage and refuse within the City limits shall be paid and collected as provided in Section 4.408 of the Springfield Municipal Code.
Section 16. Rate Stability.
(1) The Franchisee may, not later than June 30th of any calendar year, apply for an
adjustment in rate.
(2) In determining rates the City may give due consideration to all relevant factors
including, but not limited to, the following: (a) Rates charged by collection services in other Oregon cities;
(b) The most recent January Consumer Price Index (CPI-U) for Portland, Oregon;
(c) The current schedule of any rates required by Lane County; and
(d) Proposals made by Franchisee regarding an appropriate rate schedule.
(3) Non-scheduled services may be provided for a reasonable charge by Franchisee.
(4) Rate adjustments may be made not more often than once per calendar year, provided,
however: (a) A supplemental rate adjustment may be requested when the cost of service is
increased or decreased by governmental or environmental regulations in compliance
therewith; and
(b) Disposal cost established by a unit of local government having jurisdiction
may be immediately passed on to customers.
Section 17. Annual Report. The Franchisee shall submit not later than August 15th of each
year during the term of this franchise to the City of Springfield an annual-report regarding the
franchise operations which shall include the following:
(1) Activities in compliance and furtherance of the opportunity to recycle;
Attachment 2, Page 4 of 5
PAGE 5 of 5
(2) Number of customers and changes in number of customers from previous report;
(3) Number of delinquent accounts and methods for collection;
(4) Number of complaints received regarding service and the resolution of those com-
plaints;
(5) Any changes in equipment or disposal and dumping facility or sites; (6) Summary of assistance to City beautification efforts; and
(7) Accidents or problems encountered in providing the franchise service.
Section 18. Transfer. Franchisee shall not transfer this franchise in any way or any
interest therein or transfer any ownership interest in the franchise, including but not limited to the
transfer of Franchisee stock without the prior written approval of the City, which consent shall not
be withheld if the proposed transferee meets all the requirements imposed by this franchise and
applicable requirements of the municipal code relating to sanitation.
Section 19. Insurance. Franchisee shall provide a certificate of insurance to the City
demonstrating comprehensive general liability and automobile liability coverage in the combined single limit of $2,000,000 bodily injury and property damage with the City as a named additional insured.
Section 20. Effective Date. This ordinance shall take effect 30-days after adoption by
the Council and approval by the Mayor.
ADOPTED by the Common Council of the City of Springfield this day of, by a vote of ________
for and ________ against.
APPROVED by the Mayor of the City of Springfield this ________ day of ________________,
2017.
______________________________________ Mayor
ATTEST:
____________________________________
City Recorder
Attachment 2, Page 5 of 5